05-10-2016, 02:04 PM
(05-10-2016, 12:09 PM)syscrash Wrote: You are confusing is interpretation of facts. And the judgments made based on the facts. example how sex is handled on the show. Adalind and Juliette have sleep with several characters on the show. To say they are immoral justifying calling them a slut is using your belief and not the fact to define your opinion.
The same with the accusation of Juliette killed Nicks mom, or Adalind raped Nick. Both are opinions based on belief. Not statements of fact. I support anyones right to hold these moral opinions. It is when these positions are used to insist they are right that becomes a problem.
Syscrach... as you named no one in your post and I posted that I considered valid any interpretation of the show; I am considering that your post is specifically to me.
And, in my opinion, this is one of the problems with some posts in the forum. Anyone can felt offended by the accusation of being unable to understand the difference between interpretation and judgment. This kind of open affirmation can end up in things getting out of control, like Gretel appropriately wrote.
(05-09-2016, 12:01 AM)Gretel Hanselsister Wrote: The problem starts,... When people start reading between the lines, when they feel verbally attacked, things get out of control.
Specifically about your post, what is the limit of a moral judgment from a fact interpretation?
I will use your post. I can’t agree with you that calling Juliette a slut is the something as considering her guilty for killing Kelly. While the first opinion is based on personal believes (as you said), the second one is based on many questions that the writers left behind without answer for us to findout one and build up our own interpretation of the show.
Was Juliette intelligent enough to realize Kenneth real intentions were to kill Kelly?
Did Kenneth tell Juliette his real intentions about Kelly?
Did Juliette choose to not know what was going on?
Did Juliette simply do care about it?
Juliette may not have participated actively in Kelly’s death, but all of those questions (and others) are open for answers that allow everyone here to build up their own opinion.
My point is still the same… I will not judge anyones opinion. I will respect and try to understand it.