(06-20-2018, 06:13 AM)irukandji Wrote: I presume the intent behind these question is merely baiting, and you don't really expect an answer. However, I will provide one as well as some questions to you, which I'm sure you will ignore.
Was Juliette given any background on the suppression potion? Was Juliette told why the potion had to be delivered to her at the spice shop? Was she told that not only would Nick be at the spice shop, but Monroe, Hank, and Rosalee would be in attendance as well? Was she told why it would take 4 people to give her 1 jar of suppression potion? Was she told Nick and Hank would be armed? Was she told what they would do if she refused to take the potion?
As for Rosalee, she made it clear in the jail whose side she was on. She told Juliette that she and Monroe needed Nick as a grimm more than Juliette needed him as a true human. It's also not unheard of for one friend to be grateful to another. Yet where did friend Rosalee even once thank Juliette for helping her and Monroe out so they could have the luxury of Nick the grimm to help them?
Juliette's tirade-Well, what can I say that you don't already know? She wasn't alone in escalating the tension in the spice shop. If the scoobies weren't expecting some kind of confrontation, why then did Nick and Hank show up armed with guns? Why did Monroe have to be there?
If Rosalee was really the one and true friend you seem to believe she is, then she would have at the very least provided Juliette with neutral meeting place that was agreeable to the two of them alone. She would have been honest and provided a background on how the potion came to be. She would have insisted that Nick, Hank, and Monroe attend to their jobs, and not be hanging around, loitering and asking for trouble. She wouldn't have assumed Juliette would be dumb enough just to walk in to wherever and down the contents, merely because the scoobies wanted it that way.
Your question, "did Rosalee deserve to be attacked"?
My question in return, "did Juliette deserve to know the whole truth behind the spice shop meeting"?
Juliette agreed to go the Spice Shop after Nick called her so saying Rosalee should've provided a neutral place is moot since she went to the shop because of Nick which she could've refused. The Spice Shop belongs to Rosalee so she had to know someone other than Nick would be there. Monroe letting Rosalee meet her without him is something Juliette would know wouldn't happen. The only possible surprise she could've had was Hank.
You say Juliette deserved to know the truth behind the meeting. She was told the reason so that isn't the issue.
If I didn't watch the show and read what you wrote I would likely take your word for things and agree with you. But, I did watch the show so I know you're leaving key details out. There were a sequence of events that happened between Juliette being in jail and that meeting at the Spice Shop that would influence how things were handled there.
Even so, the scoobies were never threatening. Juliette had a choice of taking the potion. You said she deserved to know what would happen if she refused to take the potion. You are painting a picture that involves a negative outcome for Juliette if she refused to take the potion. Remember that the scoobies didn't attack Juliette until after she shook the shop and threw Rosalee across the room. She certainly wasn't worried about what would happen if she refused to take the potion since she provoked them into attacking.
I suppose you could say they didn't all need to be there to give her the suppressant. Therefore, you could say the opposite is also true. There were more people present to give her the potion to transform into Adalind. You could say only Nick and Elizabeth needed to be there when that happened but Monroe, Trubel, and Rosalee were all there as well.