04-01-2016, 09:14 PM
(03-30-2016, 02:48 AM)Hexenadler Wrote:(03-29-2016, 08:35 PM)Mart Wrote: First, she didn't even know Wu was scratched as Wu didn't know or realized it himself at that time being high on adrenaline and all that was going on, so how could she? Is she Jesus?
No, just someone with half a brain.
Quote:But even if she saw the scratch - why would she assume something could happen, if there was nothing about that written in the books or in the stories she was told about that defect?
Then why did she and Monroe already know so much about the defect to start with? The writers simply choose whatever plot development is the most convenient to them, and to hell with consistency or logic.
Quote:I'm not a huge fan of the later seasons development either, but this is really making up inconsisties that just aren't there.
I'm not making up anything, Mart. This is more of a case of you trying to use duct tape to cover said inconsistencies (smooth spelling, by the way) and shutting down anyone who points out the plot holes through your own faulty arguments. I've seen this used on other people in different forums who attempt to constructively criticize a story, and it was just as obnoxious then as it is now.
I don't know what forums you frequent but I've seen this the most in Game of Thrones threads. You can make the most constructive criticism but you'll be labeled a hater. In other instances, you may get the femanazi or SJW label. Believe me, this forum isn't as nearly as apologetic as those threads can be. I'm a fan of GOT but some people think that show is above criticism and anyone who disagrees should leave immediately.
As for Rosalee, I think she would be very concerned if she had known Wu was scratched. The uncertainty of the consequences of being scratched by a Lycanthrope would be very scary. I think she would want to keep an eye on Wu if they were going to be consistent with her character.