01-24-2018, 08:36 AM
(This post was last modified: 01-24-2018, 08:43 AM by Henry of green.)
(01-24-2018, 08:06 AM)Hell Rell Wrote:(01-24-2018, 06:57 AM)syscrash Wrote: The show stated in season one that it was Juliettes house. Later it was shown Nick and Juliette moving in together. When Juliette lost her memory Nick moved out and Juliette said she was going home. The bottom line the show never established legal ownership. The writers only established that Nick and Juliette lived together in the house.
You know as much about who owned the house as you know who paid the mortgage or even if there was a mortgage. That is information that was not important to the show so the writers did not address it. So to follow your logic that Nick was the owner. That would mean he was the only one on the mortgage. That means you think the single income of a Portland detective would qualify to buy that house. It is more likely that Juliette having to have a DVM would qualify more then Nick would. You see the problem with using logic. That is why the writers do not try and us logic. They just state Nick sold the house without consideration of the logistics that would make that possible.
That's how I see this issue on the show as well. The ownership of the house wasn't really established. It really is mostly conjecture here because I do remember it being called Juliette's house earlier and Nick's house later on. If you would've asked me whose house it was at the end of season 2, I would've said it belonged to Juliette.
I'm actually with you on not applying logic in this case because it certainly wasn't on the show. It was definitely done for convenience because it falls apart under any examination.
Nick said in season 5 episode 3 he bought the and Nick also sold the House theses facts are hard to ignore. Juliette never once in the entire show said she bought the house these are facts. Below script is from 5x03.
How long have you lived in this house? Shh.
About six and a half years.
I never thought I'd be here forever, but I didn't know anything about being a Grimm when I bought it Now that I think about it, you were my first.
First what? First woge I ever saw.
Remember that? You were coming out of a coffee shop.
Nick clearly says he bought it, Juliette in the entire show never claims she bought the house. are you guys claiming Nick was lying when he said clearly he bought the house.
Read more: https://www.springfieldspringfield.co.uk...ode=s05e03